Skip to main content

Recovery & surgery

Getting a Second Opinion on Upper Limb Surgery

When a second opinion is worth seeking before upper limb surgery, how to arrange one, and what to bring.

Dr Chris Conyard

Medically reviewed by Dr Chris Conyard

Upper Limb Orthopaedic Surgeon · Woolloongabba, Brisbane

Published 8 October 2026 · Reviewed 7 October 2026

The short answer

A second opinion is worth seeking before major elective surgery, where the recommendation does not match your understanding, where non operative options have not been discussed, or where you simply do not feel confident. Bring all imaging and a written history. It is a normal part of medical practice, not a criticism of your surgeon.

When a second opinion is reasonable

Before major elective surgery. Shoulder replacement, complex reconstruction and any procedure with a long recovery.

When surgery is recommended at the first consultation for a condition that usually responds to non operative treatment. Tennis elbow, shoulder impingement and mild carpal tunnel syndrome normally warrant a genuine trial of other measures first.

When you do not understand the reasoning. If you cannot explain in your own words why the operation is recommended and what happens without it, you are not yet in a position to consent.

When alternatives were not discussed. Every recommendation should include what happens if you do nothing.

When the diagnosis is uncertain, or when treatment so far has not matched the expected response.

When a previous operation has not worked. Revision decisions are more complex and benefit from another perspective.

When it may not add much

For clear cut, time critical problems, delay carries its own cost. A displaced fracture, an acute distal biceps rupture or a tendon laceration all have narrow windows where early treatment is substantially better. In those situations seeking a second opinion is still possible but should be arranged quickly rather than over weeks.

How to arrange one

  1. Ask your general practitioner for a referral and a copy of the correspondence
  2. Request copies of your imaging, the actual images rather than only the reports
  3. Tell the new specialist it is a second opinion, so they know the context
  4. Book with someone genuinely independent rather than a colleague in the same practice, unless subspecialty training makes that the sensible choice

What to bring

  • All imaging on disc or with access details
  • Reports from the first specialist
  • A written timeline of symptoms and treatment with dates
  • A list of what you have tried and for how long
  • Your questions, written down
  • For workers compensation matters, your claim details

Questions worth asking both

  • What exactly is the diagnosis, and how confident are you
  • What happens if I do nothing
  • What non operative options remain
  • What does the surgery involve and what is the recovery
  • What are the realistic chances of improvement
  • What are the risks specific to me
  • How many of these do you do
  • What would you do in my position

If the opinions differ

This is common and usually reflects genuine uncertainty in the evidence rather than error. Shoulder impingement, grade three AC joint injuries and SLAP tears are all areas where reasonable surgeons disagree.

Ask each to explain their reasoning. Look at which opinion better accounts for your particular circumstances: your job, your activities and what you need the arm to do. Where a major decision remains unclear, a third opinion is reasonable.

Frequently asked questions

Will my surgeon be offended?
A reasonable surgeon will not be. Second opinions are a normal part of medical practice, particularly before elective surgery. If a surgeon reacts badly to the suggestion, that is itself useful information about how questions will be handled later in your care.
Do I need a new referral?
Yes, you will generally need a referral from your general practitioner to access the Medicare rebate for the new specialist. Your GP can also help you decide whether a second opinion is warranted and who would be appropriate to see.
What if the two opinions differ?
Differing opinions usually reflect genuine uncertainty rather than one doctor being wrong. Ask each to explain their reasoning, what they would expect if you did nothing, and what evidence supports their approach. Sometimes a third opinion is reasonable where the decision is major.

Disclaimer: this article is general information only and is not medical advice. Individual circumstances vary. Discuss any decision about surgery with your own treating doctors.

Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks. Before proceeding, you should seek a second opinion from an appropriately qualified health practitioner.

Ready to discuss your options?

Whether you're a patient seeking treatment, a GP looking to refer, or a case manager arranging an assessment, we're here to help.

Call
Book / Refer