Skip to main content

WorkCover

Permanent Impairment Assessment for Upper Limb Injuries

What a permanent impairment assessment involves for shoulder, elbow and hand injuries, and what the outcome means.

Dr Chris Conyard

Medically reviewed by Dr Chris Conyard

Upper Limb Orthopaedic Surgeon · Woolloongabba, Brisbane

Published 8 October 2026 · Reviewed 7 October 2026

The short answer

A permanent impairment assessment measures lasting loss of function once your condition has stabilised. For upper limb injuries it assesses range of movement, strength, sensation and specific diagnostic factors against published guidelines. The result is expressed as a percentage and may lead to a lump sum offer. Legal advice before responding is sensible.

When it happens

Only once your condition is stable and stationary, meaning further meaningful improvement is not expected. For upper limb surgery this is typically around twelve months after the operation, sometimes longer for complex injuries.

Assessing earlier would produce an inaccurate figure, because you would still be improving.

What is assessed

For shoulder, elbow, wrist and hand injuries the assessment usually covers:

  • Range of movement, measured in each direction with a goniometer
  • Strength, often with grip and pinch measurement compared to the other side
  • Sensation, where nerve injury is involved
  • Specific diagnostic factors, such as joint replacement, instability or amputation
  • Effect on the whole person, since upper limb impairment is converted to a whole person figure

The assessment is performed against published guidelines, which set out how each element is measured and combined. The methodology is prescriptive rather than a matter of the examiner's general impression.

What happens during the appointment

History of the injury, treatment and current symptoms, followed by detailed physical measurement. It is usually longer than an ordinary consultation. Measurements are often repeated to check consistency.

Consistency matters. Effort during strength testing is assessed, and marked inconsistency between measurements, or between the examination and observed function, is noted in the report.

The straightforward approach is to give genuine effort and to describe your symptoms accurately, including that they fluctuate if they do.

What happens afterwards

The report goes to the insurer, which issues a notice of assessment setting out the degree of permanent impairment. This may be accompanied by a lump sum offer.

You generally have options at this point, including accepting the offer, seeking a review of the assessment, or pursuing other legal avenues. These choices interact with each other in ways that are not always obvious.

This is the point at which independent legal advice matters most. Accepting a lump sum can close off other avenues. Time limits apply. Advice before responding is far more useful than advice afterwards.

Preparing

  • Take a written summary of the injury, treatment and current limitations
  • Bring all imaging
  • Keep a diary for a week or two beforehand noting what you can and cannot do, and how symptoms vary
  • Note tasks you have had to give up or modify, at work and at home
  • List current medications

An important distinction

A low impairment percentage does not mean the injury has not affected you. The guidelines measure anatomical and functional loss in a standardised way, not the impact on your particular occupation and life. A small measured impairment can still end a career in a trade that requires sustained overhead work. That effect is addressed through different mechanisms, which is another reason to get advice.

Frequently asked questions

What does stable and stationary mean?
It means your condition has reached the point where further significant improvement is not expected with continued treatment. Impairment cannot be meaningfully assessed before that point, because the figure would change. Reaching it does not mean you are back to normal, only that you have plateaued.
Is impairment the same as disability?
No, and the distinction matters. Impairment is a measurement of loss of function of the body part, assessed against published guidelines. Disability describes the effect on your life and work. Two people with identical impairment ratings can be affected very differently depending on their occupation.
Should I accept a lump sum offer?
That is a decision to make with independent legal advice, not a medical one. Accepting an offer can affect other legal avenues that may be open to you, and those consequences are not always obvious. Time limits apply, so seek advice promptly rather than late.

Disclaimer: this article is general information only. It is not medical or legal advice. Assessment methodology and entitlements vary by jurisdiction and change over time. Seek independent legal advice about your own claim.

Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks. Before proceeding, you should seek a second opinion from an appropriately qualified health practitioner.

Ready to discuss your options?

Whether you're a patient seeking treatment, a GP looking to refer, or a case manager arranging an assessment, we're here to help.

Call
Book / Refer